| Tenure | Pastor |
|---|
| 1996-Present | E. MARIE GASAU (Shared with Thomasville) |
| 1995-1996 | E. MARIE GASAU (Shared with Thomasville) & LINDA METCALF, Local Pastor |
| 1992-1995 | THOMAS DUDLEY (Shared with Thomasville) & LINDA METCALF, Local Pastor |
| 1978-1992 | JAMES WILLIAM MOORE (Shared with Thomasville) |
| 1991 | LINDA METCALF, appointed Local Pastor |
| 1974-1978 | LYNN SPARKS (Shared with Carbondale & Thomasville) |
| 1966-1974 | JAMES WILLIAM CAVENDER (Shared with Carbondale & Thomasville) |
| 1968 | NAME CHANGE TO BASALT COMMUNITY UNITED METHODIST CHURCH
and THOMASVILLE COMMUNITY UNITED METHODIST CHURCH |
| 1966-1965 | ADA BEATRICE DUHIGG & MILDRED MAY (Shared with Thomasville) |
| 02/07/65 | CHARTER SERVICE OF THOMASVILLE METHODIST CHURCH |
| SUMMER 1964 | ADA BEATRICE DUHIGG & DEACONESS MILDRED MAY (With Mission to Thomasville) |
| 1960-1965 | KEITH MERRIMAN (Shared with Aspen) |
| 1956-1960 | DOYLE K. HAUSCHULZ (Shared with Aspen) |
| 1953-1956 | BRONSTON M. GREENWOOD (Shared with Aspen) |
| 07/08/54 | NAME CHANGE TO BASALT COMMUNITY METHODIST CHURCH from
JOHN BENNETT MEMORIAL METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH |